Has price erosion ended (or slowed down) in security?
Editor Introduction
One impact of Chinese companies entering the physical security market has been an erosion in product pricing, creating what has been called the "race to the bottom". However, political forces and cybersecurity concerns have presented new challenges for Chinese companies. Adding cybersecurity increases costs, and the addition of more functionality to edge devices is another trend that has impacted product pricing. We asked this week's Expert Panel Roundtable: Has price erosion ended (or slowed down) in the security market?
Price erosion or commoditisation in the security market has shifted to other aspects of the business instead of slowing down. Price wars were fought at the low end of the market where manufacturers typically cut corners (lower specs and limited cybersecurity measures). However, $50 per camera on a high-volume sale makes it hard to further reduce costs. Now low-end, price-driven video manufacturers introduce 4K resolution cameras at extremely low prices. Recently we have also witnessed a lowering of the cost of VMS software licenses with some manufacturers who sell both cameras and software, giving away free VMS licenses with the cameras in an effort to lock the customer into their brand of camera. In my mind, the industry should educate the customer of the true value of the features and benefits of the products being developed.
In Europe, we began to see the “race to the bottom” come to an end last year. The main driving force was concerns over surveillance cybersecurity, meaning manufacturers competing less often on price. We’ve seen many low-cost players retreat to re-engineer and eliminate vulnerabilities and “back doors”. That cost is reflected in pricing, plus cyber and quality concerns make it easier to sell against lower-priced, inferior products. The U.S. ban and widespread criticism of Chinese tech continue to have a significant impact with vendors eliminated from projects simply due to country of origin. These same companies are investing heavily in lobbyists and marketing to fight back, while simultaneously incurring the costs of overseas expansion. This has led to fewer price cuts in Europe where Chinese players are keen to offset poor U.S. sales. Users are now more likely to consider lifecycle costs, and which means looking beyond initial price points.
Certainly, the price of access control readers and credentials have seen an apparent price erosion over the last couple of decades. It’s inevitable that as volumes of products go up, the costs go down – that’s simple economics. When you consider the huge scale of production in China and other parts of Southeast Asia, it’s not hard to see why. These high-volume producers have lowered their cost base to account for the reductions in selling price. This approach has always been common; there are always producers that will choose to join a market and disrupt it! The change now, though, is that many security providers are choosing to sell services and support to accompany products, and this is where the profits are to be found. The way end users spend on their security is changing, and this has helped to mitigate many of the potential issues from price erosion.
Price erosion in the security market, in general, appears to be slowing down. The political pressure on Chinese products has tamped down demand for these products in favour of other manufacturers. However, uncertainty breeds opportunity, so it would not be surprising to see another low price/low margin manufacturer appear to fill any Chinese void. An existing manufacturer could also step up, looking for a “land grab” opportunity before the Chinese situation settles out. In any case, I would expect to see prices begin to creep up over the next 9 to 12 months, particularly on commoditised products. One school of thought also says that we have reached the bottom everyone has been racing towards, and prices just cannot go any lower without a quantum leap advancement in technology. Moore’s Law is alive and well and chip technology continues to advance, so that quantum leap could be closer than we think.
Editor Summary
Lower-priced security products can be tempting. However, a need for better quality and more functionality, not to mention a greater emphasis on the total cost of ownership, can offset the temptation to buy based solely on price in many applications. Manufacturers are continuing to seek new ways to add value to their products, and to justify a decent pricing level that will ensure they continue to thrive financially. Value trumps cost, and adding value is the best antidote to price erosion.
- Related companies
- TDSi
- 3xLOGIC, Inc.
- Hanwha Vision (formerly Hanwha Techwin America)
- IDIS
- Related categories
- CCTV software
- IP cameras
- Access control readers
- View all news from
- TDSi
- 3xLOGIC, Inc.
- Hanwha Vision (formerly Hanwha Techwin America)
- IDIS
Expert commentary
Security beat
Security bytes
- Getting to know Dan Grimm, VP and General Manager of Computer Vision at RealNetworks
- Big wins and the importance of showing up: Insights from SourceSecurity.com editor Larry Anderson
- Setting goals, business travels and radioactivity: Success secrets from Tiandy's John van den Elzen
- Getting to know Jeff Burgess, President/CEO at BCDVideo
Mobile access articles
HID Global, a provider trusted identity solutions, announced the OMNIKEY Secure Element that sets a new simplicity standard for reader manufacturers and others integrating RFID-based security technolo...
HID®, a worldwide pioneer in trusted identity solutions, announced that Baiduri Bank, a member of Baiduri Bank Group and the largest conventional bank in Brunei Darussalam, has implement...
The revolutionary approach to mobile access taken by ABLOY CUMULUS has been recognised by ISJ’s 2024 Leaders in Security Awards. ABLOY CUMULUS was named the 2024 winner in the Innovation Initia...
Genetec Inc., a major technology provider of unified security, public safety, operations, and business intelligence solutions, is pleased to announce its debut at PropTech Connect, taking place at the...
iDenfy, a Lithuania-based RegTech company offering automated KYC/KYB and AML solutions, partnered with Gopher, an innovative on-demand marketplace that connects users with qualified local workers for...
Sustainability is a hot topic. Everyone knows about it. Governments have active Net Zero strategies and implementation plans, while organisations are establishing plans and activities to reduce their...
Zimperium, the global pioneer in mobile security, is proud to announce that it’s collaborating with Okta, the independent identity provider to deliver a significant advancement in identity threa...
HiveWatch, a physical security software company reimagining how organisations keep their people and assets safe, announced a partnership with globally renowned security technology provider - SAGE Inte...
Morse Watchmans, the industry pioneer in key control and asset management systems, will showcase its innovative key control solutions for correctional facilities at the 154th American Correctional Ass...
Pyronix is excited to unveil the BatteryCam2 and SolarPanel2, designed to upgrade security peace-of-mind with exceptional performance and convenience. With the fully wireless BatteryCam2, prope...
Having doors with mechanical security can be a drag on the effectiveness and efficiency of facilities management. While wiring ever more locks to make access control more flexible is expensive and dis...
HID, the worldwide pioneer in trusted identity solutions, announces that the University of Dundee is updating its city campus estate implementing HID® Mobile Access® and signature HID Signo&tr...
Skills for Security is proud to announce a new partnership with Eaton, a global pioneer in power management solutions. Eaton has joined Skills for Security as a Platinum Sponsor, marking a significant...
G2E Asia and Asian IR Expo attracted more than 6,300 industry professionals to Macau in June 2024, with international attendees accounting for 65 percent of total attendance. The significant turnout...
Allegion US, a pioneer in seamless access control solutions, announced a new integration with TagMaster North America (TMNA), a pioneering provider of intelligent vehicle identification solutions (Lic...
Security practices for hotels
DownloadAccess control system planning phase 2
DownloadHoneywell GARD USB threat report 2024
DownloadSIA Identity and Biometrics Symposium
DownloadFacial recognition
DownloadHID Signo™ Biometric Reader 25B - Multi-technology, mobile ready, fingerprint reader
Anviz 8MP AI-Powered Mini Dome Network Camera with 360° Clarity
Verkada Monitored Alarm System